Posted July 23, 2018

The Case for Banning Airbnb & Short-stay in Apartment Buildings

The Case for Banning Airbnb & Short-stay in Apartment Buildings

Are Apartment Buildings Equipped for Airbnb and Short Stays?

The recent tragic death of a young woman at a Melbourne short-stay apartment raises serious questions about the suitability of residential buildings for this type of accommodation. Are apartment buildings truly equipped to handle the unique challenges posed by short-term rentals, or are we putting residents at risk?

A Growing Problem

In recent times, Melbourne has seen a rise in incidents involving short-stay properties rented by groups of young people for parties. These gatherings often spiral out of control, resulting in property damage, disturbances, and even violence. The latest incident, occurring on the 56th floor of the EQ Tower, highlights the potential for serious consequences.

Oversight and Management Challenges

Most apartment buildings rely on an owners corporation management company and a volunteer committee to oversee the property. These managers typically handle administrative tasks, budgeting, and maintenance. However, they often lack the on-site presence and expertise to effectively manage issues arising from short-term rentals, especially those involving unruly guests.

While some larger buildings may have on-site building managers and security guards, many lack 24-hour staffing and the specialised knowledge needed to handle situations like out-of-control parties. This leaves residents vulnerable and raises concerns about the adequacy of current management structures.

Apartment Buildings vs. Hotels

Unlike hotels, which are designed and staffed to handle a constant flow of guests, apartment buildings are primarily residential spaces. Hotels have 24-hour staff, experience in managing guest behaviour, and established protocols for handling disturbances. Apartment buildings often lack these resources and expertise.

The Role of Short-Stay Operators

The rise of short-stay operators managing multiple units within a building adds another layer of complexity. While these operators may have on-site staff, their primary focus is often on maximising rental income rather than ensuring compliance with building rules and resident well-being.

Balancing Rights and Responsibilities

The increasing popularity of short-term rentals raises important questions about balancing the rights of investors with the needs and expectations of owner-occupiers. While investors seek financial returns, residents deserve peaceful enjoyment of their homes and a safe living environment.

Conclusion

The recent tragedy highlights the need for a serious conversation about the suitability of apartment buildings for short-term rentals. It’s crucial to address the gaps in oversight, management, and security to ensure the safety and well-being of all residents.

Contact us today for a free consultation. We’ll help you find a management company that prioritises your needs.

Written by
Change Body Corporate
The contents of this article or website are only intended to provide a general overview of the topics discussed. The author of this article makes no representations as to the accuracy or completeness of any information and the information is not intended to constitute investment, legal or professional advice. You should seek professional advice before acting or relying on any of the content. This article does not contain references to any specific company, organisation or individual, unless expressly specified.
Still looking for answers your manager should be giving you?
We help Committees of 10+ lot buildings who are tired of being left in the dark. Tell us what’s going on, and we’ll help you move forward.

    Please note: Our services are exclusively for Committees of buildings with 10 lots or more.

    Common Property Boundaries and the Water Act – Who is Liable for Unreasonable Flows of Water into an Apartment?

    The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal has published a decision that provides some further clarity as to how a Plan of Subdivision is interpreted to determine the boundaries between the…

    Body Corporates Cannot Prohibit Use of Short Term Letting of Apartments

    Bodies Corporate In July 2016, The Supreme Court of Victoria handed down an important decision in Owners Corporation PS 501391P v Balcombe [2016] VSC 384 (Balcombe case) regarding whether a…

    Do We Need a Body Corporate Manager? What Self-Managed Owners Often Learn the Hard Way 

    For most owners corporations in Victoria, appointing a body corporate manager is a choice, not a legal requirement.   But that choice comes with real accountability and understanding where self-management…

    Black v Body Corporate OC1-POS539033E [2018] VCAT 185

    Introduction In this case, the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal considered whether a body corporate had unlawfully discriminated against a resident in a residential development by failing to make alterations…

    Cladding Rectification Victoria: What Body Corporates Need to Know

    Article contributed by James Collier, Partner – Moray and Agnew Lawyers Victorian Building Amendment (Cladding Rectification) Bill 2019: A Closer Look The Victorian Legislative Assembly recently introduced the Building…

    Update from Strata Management Consultants Melbourne

    As we are once again pushed back into Stage 3 lockdowns across Melbourne, we are writing to let you know that we are still open for business during this challenging…

    The Perils of Applying the Benefit Principle Under the Owners Corporation Act

    Building defects rarely arrive as a simple maintenance issue. Once a defect is found in common property, the conversation can quickly shift from “what needs to be repaired?” to “who…

    Victorian Body Corporate Reform: Still Waiting After All These Years

    Victorian Body Corporate Reform: A Decade of Frustration and a Glimmer of Hope It’s 2024, and Victorian apartment owners are still grappling with the consequences of delayed reforms in…

    Body Corporate Management Update: Owner Gets to Keep Balcony

    Who is responsible for fixing a balcony on common property that has fallen into disrepair but was constructed without the approval of the body corporate? The answer may surprise you.

    Top 10 Body Corporate Issues in Victoria and How to Handle Them

    If you live in a body corporate property, you have probably seen how quickly small issues can become bigger problems. One resident parks in the wrong spot. A pet causes…

    Busting the myth: “If there’s a lift and pool – the body corporate levies skyrocket”

    One of our directors was in the gym one morning and inadvertently overheard a conversation between two people. The older guy walked in, greeted his friend, and they got…

    Helping Large Owners Corporations to Change Management Companies and Improve the Running of their Buildings

    It has been a very busy past few months and year for us at Change Body Corporate. We have had many conversations with industry contacts, our…